As the football world prepares for the 2034 FIFA World Cup, speculation is rife about potential international host venues. Oft-mentioned is Saudi Arabia, a kingdom recognized for its vast wealth, bold application of Vision 2030, and keen preference for projecting more progressive images on the global stage.
However, Saudi Arabia’s suitability as one of these prestigious occasions raises major concerns, mainly about censorship. Heavy censorship of media and online content can severely limit the ability of fanatics, from every neighborhood and the global world, to communicate freely, posing a serious risk to the spirit of the FIFA World Cup.
The Land of Censorship in Saudi Arabia
Saudi Arabia is characterized by a strict censorship regime, especially when it comes to media and networks. The authorities control what can be published, broadcast, or made available online, creating an atmosphere of fear and repression. In 2024, Saudi Arabia was positioned 166th out of 180 countries in the World Press Freedom Index, achieving a score of 27.14.
The consequences of such censorship spread beyond politics into the realm of sporting activities, traditions, and social interplay. For fans attending the World Cup, being able to freely share their reviews, opinions, and emotions is essential to the atmosphere of the occasion. However, in a country where even minor criticism can have serious consequences, the vibrancy of fan engagement will be stifled.
Limited Access to Information
In a globalized world, sports enthusiasts rely heavily on media coverage and online systems to access facts about events, teams, and players. However, much of the media landscape in Saudi Arabia is tightly controlled, limiting access to diverse perspectives and important analysis. In 2022, Saudi authorities detained at least 15 individuals for their online activities, imposing sentences that ranged from 10 to 45 years.
This loss of right of entry can seriously hinder enthusiasts from preparing for the World Cup. Important records of matches, venues, and player conditions may be censored or distorted, mainly due to distorted information about the occasion. For international enthusiasts, arriving in Saudi Arabia with limited information can cause confusion and frustration, which will detract from the general enjoyment of the tournament.
Impact on Freedom of Expression
One of the most profound consequences of censorship is its effect on freedom of expression. Soccer is more than just a sport; it is a platform for lovers to express their identity, ideals, and feelings. For many, the FIFA World Cup is a second moment of pride and party, where numerous cultures come together to share their love of the game. However, in a repressive environment, enthusiasts may also experience an inability to express their authentic feelings or interact in discussions about the event, groups, or even the host state.
According to Freedom House, Saudi Arabia has a Global Freedom Score of 8 out of 100, classifying it as “not free.” Its Internet Freedom Score is even lower at 25 out of 100, indicating significant restrictions on online expression. This suppression undermines the essence of the FIFA World Cup, which thrives on passion, joy, and shared experiences. When enthusiasts can’t express themselves, the precise culture that comes with international sporting opportunities diminishes.
Restrictions on Social Networks
Social media has revolutionized the way fans interact with sports activities. Platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook allow enthusiasts to share their thoughts, enjoy their groups, and interact in discussions. However, in Saudi Arabia, social media is difficult to strictly regulate. Content deemed inappropriate, critical of the authorities, or contrary to Islamic values is often censored.
This presents a huge problem for the World Cup. Fans from across the sector use social media to connect with everyone, share their experiences, and cheer on their teams. If Saudi Arabia were to host the tournament, global fanatics could find their involvement with the local subculture limited by censorship of social media structures. This should make for a less lively environment, as lovers may not be able to share their experiences in real time, reducing the global community’s connection to the event.
Lack of Cultural Freedom
Censorship in Saudi Arabia extends beyond the media; in addition, it includes cultural expressions. Art, music, and various types of cultural representation are often under scrutiny, mainly due to a lack of creativity and innovation. A culturally rich game, football is deeply connected to local customs, traditions, and celebrations. In a country where cultural expressions are strictly monitored, the authenticity of these celebrations can be compromised.
The World Cup is an opportunity for cultures to come together and showcase specific traditions and celebrations from across the sector. In Saudi Arabia, the chance of cultural homogenization due to censorship should result in a lack of vibrant neighbourhood lifestyles throughout the event. The loss of local expression should detract from the general experience for global enthusiasts, who often remain prepared to experience the host country’s subculture and traditions.
International Reputation and Human Rights
To host a global event like the FIFA World Cup requires a rustic to dare a photo of openness, inclusiveness, and recognition of human rights. Marked by accusations of human rights abuses and suppression of freedom, Saudi Arabia’s recognition raises serious questions about its suitability as a party. The record on issues such as freedom of speech, girls’ rights, and LGBTQ rights poses challenges to its image as a welcoming host for diverse enthusiasts.
Conclusion
While Saudi Arabia’s wealth and infrastructure may make it an attractive candidate to host the 2034 FIFA World Cup, the implications of censorship cannot be overlooked. Strict regulations on media and internet content threaten the very essence of what makes the FIFA World Cup such a unique and popular event: the ability of fans to communicate freely, express their emotions, and have fun with their cultures. As the sector increasingly values freedom of expression, inclusivity, and the appreciation of human rights, it is crucial for FIFA not to lose sight of the wider implications of choosing Saudi Arabia as the host country.
